The Light of One Lantern: Making Room for Different Beliefs
A gnome hugging a cross sparked a disagreement. Gnomean Proverb 1 offers a way to make room for the person holding a different lantern.
Somebody posted a picture of a gnome hugging a cross in the Church of Gnome group. A few people wondered why Christian imagery belonged there. Some had thought they were joining a Pagan space. I understand why a picture like that can bring up real feelings. It also put a question in front of us: what did we think we were promising when we said people were welcome here?
The Lantern Proverb
Let’s sit with that proverb for a moment. “The light of one lantern does not diminish another; it only makes the path brighter.” It’s simple, but when you really reflect on it… it’s can be powerful. Because we live in a world where a lot of people are convinced that for their light to matter, someone else’s has to be snuffed out. That truth is a competition. That there’s only so much space on the stage. That if you’re right, then I must be wrong. But light doesn’t work that way. Not spiritually. Not emotionally. Not communally.
If you’ve ever walked through the woods at night with a lantern – or even just a flashlight – you know how it feels when someone else joins you with their own light. Suddenly the trail becomes clearer. The shadows shrink back. You see more. Not less. That’s the vision behind this proverb. That’s the vision behind the Church of Gnome. We’re not here to tell people what lantern to carry. We’re here to say: Bring it. Share it. Light your way – and help someone else see a little further, too. Maybe your lantern is lit by Jesus. Maybe it’s lit by the moon and the old gods.
Maybe it’s lit by your own quiet intuition, or the giggle of a garden gnome statue on your windowsill. Whatever it is… it’s welcome here. Because the more we let each other shine, the richer the path becomes. Now, that doesn’t mean anything goes. There’s a difference between sharing your light… and swinging it in someone else’s face. If someone enters this space saying “my light is the only one that matters, and everyone else is lost,” – that’s not light. That’s glare. That’s ego. That’s something else entirely. But when someone says, “This is what guides me. This is how I make sense of the mystery,” – and does it with humility, not superiority – that’s sacred.
That’s what this space is meant to protect. See, a lot of spiritual communities set up walls. This is Christian. This is Pagan. This is New Age. This is Atheist. And if you don’t fit inside the box, there’s no space for you. But the Church of Gnome isn’t a box. It’s a campfire. It’s a gathering place. You don’t have to believe the same thing as the person sitting next to you. You just have to let them speak. And listen with enough openness that their lantern adds something to your view – even if just for a moment. Because even if you don’t agree with their path…
You might still see something in their light that helps you better walk your own. So when I say this proverb isn’t just decorative – it’s because I mean it. It’s how we build this church. It’s how we protect its spirit. And in the world we live in – a world full of division, outrage, and noise – this isn’t just poetic. It’s radical. Letting others shine without shrinking your own light is one of the most powerful things we can practice. And it’s something I hope this community will keep returning to, especially as we grow. Because with every new member comes a new lantern. And with every new lantern… the path gets just a little bit brighter.
Belief Has Always Been a Battlefield
Let’s be real for a moment. For most of human history, belief has been dangerous ground. And not just in a metaphorical sense. People have gone to war – literally gone to war – over whose god was the right god. Entire cultures have been wiped out because they honored a different pantheon… followed different rhythms… worshipped under different names. Even today, people are attacked – sometimes even killed – for simply existing outside of someone else's religious comfort zone. The right to believe, the right not to believe, the right to change your beliefs… these things are still controversial in parts of the world. So when I say this space is radical, I’m not just being poetic.
In a world built on religious boundaries, building a community like this – one that says “come as you are, believe what you believe, share it with respect and curiosity” – that’s not a small thing. It’s a quiet rebellion. And the truth is, even people who think they’ve left religion behind still sometimes carry those battle instincts with them. We all have it in us – the temptation to draw lines, to protect our beliefs by pushing others away.
Sometimes that instinct comes from trauma. Sometimes it comes from pride. Sometimes it just comes from fear. And it makes sense. If you’ve had to fight to reclaim your path – if you’ve had your beliefs mocked, colonized, or dismissed – you’re going to be sensitive when something that feels similar shows up in your space. I get that. I honor that. But here’s what I believe: If we want to break the cycle – if we want to do something different than what’s been done for thousands of years – we have to make room for the lanterns of others, even if they once looked like the torches that burned down our villages.
We have to make room without letting ourselves be dominated again, yes – but also without becoming the next generation of gatekeepers. It’s not easy. It’s not comfortable. But that’s what makes it powerful. In the Church of Gnome, we don’t ask you to abandon what you believe. We don’t ask you to water it down. But we do ask you to practice holding space. To say: “This is what lights my path. And even though your light looks different, I’ll walk beside you.” That is the difference between belief as a battlefield… And belief as a bridge.
And honestly? We’re doing it. Outside of the occasional flare-up, like what happened this week, the energy in this community has been overwhelmingly generous and kind. That’s rare. That tells me something important: We’re ready. We’re ready to do this differently. So let’s keep going. Let’s keep building something where belief isn’t a war – it’s a gift. Something where the weird and sacred can live side-by-side.
Something where you can talk about Odin, or Jesus, or mushroom spirits, or your grandma’s kitchen witchery – and be met with curiosity, not condemnation. Because that’s how we break the cycle. And that’s how we keep the path open for the ones still finding their way.
The meme that tested our openness
Let’s talk about the meme. A gnome hugging a cross. That’s it. It wasn’t some fire-and-brimstone post. It wasn’t a sermon. It wasn’t telling people what to believe. Just a gnome and a cross – symbols held together with love. And yet… the comment section got loud. Now I’m not bringing this up to call anyone out. I’m not interested in shame or blame. But I do think this moment revealed something important – about where we are as a community, and about how easy it is to slip into fear when something unfamiliar shows up in our space. Some of the comments said things like, “I didn’t come here to see Christian posts,” or, “This is a Pagan group,” or “Keep it Gnomean.”
But here’s the thing: The Church of Gnome isn’t Pagan. It isn’t Christian. It isn’t atheist or agnostic or esoteric or mystical. It’s all of that. And none of it. It’s a space where all of those lanterns are welcome to glow – so long as they’re held with kindness and not used as weapons. There’s a line I want to draw here because it matters: There’s a big difference between sharing your beliefs… and preaching them. Sharing says: “This is something meaningful to me.” Preaching says: “This should be meaningful to you.” And I’ll admit, it’s a blurry line sometimes. It can feel subjective. But I think we know the difference when we feel it.
Sharing invites conversation. Preaching shuts it down. That’s why I say – if you want to talk about Jesus, talk about Jesus. If you want to post about the Norse gods, the moon cycles, the Fae, the mushroom spirits, the laughter of a child, the void of nothingness – that’s all welcome here. Just do it from your heart, not from a pulpit. And if you see something that isn’t part of your spiritual language – maybe a gnome and a cross – pause for a moment before reacting. Ask yourself: “Is this post really trying to convert me? Or is someone just showing me what lights their path?” Because if it’s the latter, maybe… just maybe… we can honor it without having to adopt it.
Maybe we can say, “That’s not my lantern – but I see the glow, and I wish you well.” And if we’re going to keep this community healthy, especially as it grows, we have to cultivate that mindset. We have to become people who are curious before we’re critical. People who add to the conversation instead of tearing it down. People who remember that one meme isn’t a takeover – it’s just a tiny light. And sometimes, the most Gnomean thing you can do is shrug, smile, and say: “Not my vibe… but I’m glad it brings you peace.” That’s what real inclusivity looks like.
And that’s how we protect this movement as something different from everything else out there.
The Poll That Says It All
Now if there’s ever been proof that we are doing something truly unique here, it’s what happened when I posted a poll in the Facebook group last week. The question was simple: “How do you personally view gnomes?” Are they spiritual or elemental beings? Are they symbolic or archetypal? Are they whimsical and fun – more of a vibe than a being? And I wasn’t sure what to expect, honestly.
But over a thousand of you voted. That alone is amazing – over a thousand people felt strongly enough about their relationship to gnomes to weigh in. But here’s the part that really hit me: Roughly 70% of you said that you lean toward believing gnomes are real beings in some form – spiritual, elemental, energetic, or interdimensional. That’s wild. And also… beautiful. Because we’re not talking about some abstract deity handed down through institutions. We’re talking about gnomes – those little pointy-hatted, often misunderstood guardians of gardens, forests, boundaries, and mystery. And 70% of this community sees them as more than myth. That tells me something powerful: This isn’t a joke for people.
This isn’t kitsch or irony or just another internet niche. For many of us, it’s real. It’s meaningful. It’s part of our cosmology. But here’s the other part – and it’s just as important: Roughly 30% of you said you view gnomes more symbolically, or are just here for the humor and charm. And I want to say this just as loudly: You belong here too. Because whether you see gnomes as literal or metaphorical, sacred or silly, one thing ties us all together: There’s something about them that opens us up. That softens us. That reconnects us to mystery, nature, wonder, and community.
And that’s what makes the Church of Gnome work. It’s not about everyone seeing the same thing the same way. It’s about what happens between us when we share what we see – and stay open to what others bring to the table. You can believe gnomes are Earth elementals who whisper through tree roots. You can believe they’re psychological archetypes that represent boundary-keeping. You can believe they’re hilarious little hat-wearing tricksters who simply make the world more fun. And in the Church of Gnome… all of those lights are welcome.
Because again – the light of one lantern does not diminish another. It only makes the path brighter. And the more varied our lights, the more terrain we can illuminate. So whether you’re here for spiritual insight, playful absurdity, deep mythological roots, or just a sense of connection – you’re part of this path. You’re holding one of the lanterns. And I’m so glad you're here.
Holding Space as We Grow
So, where does all of this leave us? It leaves us with an opportunity – and a responsibility. Because what we’re doing here isn’t easy. Creating a space that welcomes radically different beliefs, spiritual languages, and cultural experiences… and still manages to feel peaceful and joyful? That’s a tightrope walk. And yet – somehow – it’s happening. Sure, every now and then there’s a flare-up. A meme. A misunderstanding. A debate that gets a little too heated. That’s to be expected in any community, especially one growing as fast as this one is. But if you zoom out, what you’ll see is something pretty extraordinary: People showing up with sincerity.
People listening to beliefs they’ve never encountered before. People laughing together, blessing each other, sharing lanterns. And I don’t take that for granted. Now, as this community keeps expanding, that balance will get trickier to maintain. We’ll have more perspectives, more ideas, more spiritual languages mixing in the same pot. And I want to be really clear: that’s not a threat. That’s a gift. But it only stays a gift if we all tend to it. So let me offer this as a gentle ask – something I hope you’ll carry with you:
When you post, share from your heart – not your podium. Let your light shine, but don’t swing it like a spotlight in someone’s face. Trust that your truth will land with the people it’s meant to reach, even if not everyone resonates. And when you comment, comment in a way that builds – not breaks. Add your view. Expand the conversation. Bring your own lantern to the trail, instead of trying to blow someone else’s out. Ask yourself, “How can I help make the path brighter for everyone – not just more comfortable for me?”
Because this is how we stay Gnomean – not by narrowing down what that means, but by staying wide open to the mystery that brought us here in the first place. And I’ll be honest – there’s a real magic in watching it happen. It’s in the posts where someone shares a gnome story from childhood and dozens of strangers jump in to say, “I see you.” It’s in the pictures of altars and gardens and gnome hats in unexpected places. It’s in people showing up as themselves, without needing to explain or justify why their path matters.
And it’s in the trust you’ve placed in this movement – in this weird and wonderful Church built on mushrooms, mystery, and the belief that humor and holiness are not opposites. We’re not always going to get it right.


