Skip to content
Definitely Not A Cult. Definitely Into Gnomes.
Gnome Talk · Episode 19

When You Don't Know What to Believe Anymore

How early brushes with religion, hardline atheism, and paranormal curiosity made room for a faith comfortable with doubt.

I didn't grow up in a deeply religious household. Belief found its way to me in pieces. Some of it came through Christianity. Some of it came through experiences I couldn't account for as a kid. I remember the feeling that there was more going on than I could see. I didn't have a doctrine for it. I had a question.

The Early Seeds

I didn’t grow up in a deeply religious household. There were no Sunday sermons. No family prayers at the dinner table. No bedtime devotions or Bible verses pinned to the fridge. But religion was around. Like the way the smell of a neighbor’s garden lingers in the air even if you’ve never stepped foot inside of it.

I have a vague memory of being taken to churcha few times when I was really little – maybe for Easter. I honestly can’t recall much beyond the feeling that I didn’t know the words to the songs, and my clothes were itchier than usual. Looking back, I think my parents probably brought us out of a kind of inherited guilt. Not out of conviction, but because their parents went to church. It was more about tradition than faith. Still, belief had a way of finding me in other places.

One of my close friends in elementary school had a very religious family. His mom was one of those deeply devout, sincere Christians. The kind of person who genuinely lived her faith – quietly, without force. I think she would’ve loved for me to become Christian, but she never pressured me. She welcomed me. Listened. Made me feel safe in their home.

Her son and I would go to a church group together called Royal Rangers. If you’ve never heard of it, it’s sort of like Christian Boy Scouts. There were uniforms, merit badges, lessons, and Bible study… but all I cared about was the Derby car races. That was the main event for me – designing your own little wooden car, sanding it down, painting it, and racing it in a tournament. That was the fun part.

But even in that space, I always felt like I was swimming upstream. I wasn’t a troublemaker by any means – in fact, I was the kind of kid teachers liked. I followed rules. Did my homework. But during Royal Rangers, I’d constantly end up standing in the corner. Not because I was being bad – but because I asked too many questions. I didn’t realize it at the time, but that pattern would follow me for years – curiosity getting mistaken for defiance. It wasn’t that I wanted to stir things up. I just wanted to understand. Why this? Why not that? What does that story really mean?

And then, at night – when the lights were out and the world got quiet – those questions only got louder. Because for years, I struggled to fall asleep. Not because of monsters under the bed, but because of what I saw. People. Figures. Standing at the foot of my bed. Sometimes they were blurry outlines. Sometimes they looked solid. One of them even spoke – said he was my great-grandfather, someone I never met. He just… stood there, calm, like he was checking in. And while it wasn’t terrifying in the Hollywood horror sense, it was overwhelming. Especially for a kid who didn’t have a spiritual framework to understand any of it.

I used to sleep with the blankets pulled all the way over my head. My parents hated that – thought I’d suffocate. But it was the only way I felt safe. Like maybe the blanket could keep the veil from thinning any further. I didn’t have the language for it back then. But I know now what I was feeling: There’s more going on than we can see. There’s something here. Something just out of reach, just beyond the curtain.

So even though I wasn’t raised in a religious home, the spiritual thread was always tugging at me – from the kindness of my friend’s mom, to the Derby races at Royal Rangers, to the questions that got me in trouble, to the silent visitors in the night. That was the seed. Not belief. Not doctrine. But wonder. And I think for a lot of people, that’s where it really starts – not with certainty, but with the realization that there’s something deeper, something invisible, something else. Not everyone talks about it. But I think more of us have felt it than we admit.

Anger, rebellion, and atheism

If childhood was the whisper that there might be more, then my teenage years were the years I shouted back. By the time I reached high school, the quiet curiosity I carried as a child had been replaced by a kind of fire. Not the destructive kind – but the kind that burns through illusion. That wants truth at any cost. That’s not content with maybe. That demands why. This was the age when everything got louder – my music, my thoughts, my feelings. And I needed something big enough to hold that intensity. That’s when I found heavy music.

I still remember the first time I heard real metal – death metal, black metal, deathcore – genres that sounded like the inside of my mind some days: wild, unfiltered. For me, it wasn’t just noise. It was catharsis. It was someone else screaming the things I didn’t yet have the courage – or the words – to say. And then I found Marilyn Manson.

Not just the music, but the interviews, the autobiography, the performance of it all. He wasn’t just a shock artist – he was sharp. I watched him dismantle accusations from televangelists and politicians, people who blamed him and others like him for everything wrong with the world – from teen violence to moral collapse. And yet, here he was, responding not with profanity or chaos, but with calm, brutal logic. With a clarity that made people uncomfortable. And that fascinated me.

I saw something I hadn’t seen in religion: the ability to think. To ask questions. To point out hypocrisy and call it what it was. I started to feel like everything I’d ever seen tied to “God” had come with a rulebook, a threat, or a veil of judgment. And now, here was someone flipping the whole narrative inside out. The more I looked around, the more hypocrisy I saw. Religious leaders living in mansions while preaching humility. Churches preaching love while actively excluding people for who they loved. The Westboro Baptist Church protesting at military funerals with signs that said “God Hates You.” As if a God who is supposedly love could ever hate someone for existing.

I didn’t just become skeptical. I became angry. And that anger needed a home. That’s when I found the Church of Satan – and before you recoil, let me clarify. It’s not about devil worship. It’s not about sacrificing goats or hexing your enemies. In fact, most Satanists don’t believe in any supernatural beings at all. What drew me in was the raw, unapologetic philosophy: You are responsible for your life.

You are accountable for your actions. Don’t blame demons. Don’t ask angels to fix it. You own your power – and your consequences. It was a radical departure from the ideas of sin and salvation I had seen shadowing the edges of my childhood. There were no confessions. No saviors. Just self. And strangely… that felt empowering. I liked the darkness. The aesthetics. The inversion of it all.

While some of my peers were wearing crosses and purity rings, I was wearing black, blasting Behemoth, and proudly quoting Anton LaVey. I wasn’t trying to scare people – I was trying to reclaim something. My voice. My mind. My right to ask questions without being sent to the corner. But even during that time – when I wore that identity like a badge – I knew it wasn’t the end of the road. Because for all its logic and empowerment, for me Satanism left no room for the mystery. It was hardline atheism. It said, this is it. What you see is what you get. There is no beyond.

And yet, I had seen beyond. I had felt things. Experienced moments that logic couldn’t fully explain. It didn’t make sense to me to throw all of that away just because it didn’t fit into a measurable worldview. So I started to feel the edges of discomfort again – this time, not from outside judgment, but from inside tension. What do you do when you’re too skeptical to believe what you’re told… …but too open-hearted to believe in nothing? I didn’t know yet. But I knew I had to keep going.

So I took what I’d learned – critical thinking, self-responsibility, discernment – and carried it with me. But I left behind the armor. Because underneath it all, I still had questions. Still had wonder. Still had that something inside me whispering: There’s more. Keep looking.

The Unfolding – Wonder, Openness, and the Paranormal

Leaving behind hardline atheism wasn’t a clean break. It wasn’t like one day I stopped identifying as a Satanist and the next day I lit incense and started meditating in the forest. It was slower than that. Subtler. Like the way a frozen lake begins to thaw – not with a dramatic crack, but with little shifts you don’t notice until suddenly, the surface is moving again. It started with questions. Not the combative kind I had when I was younger – but gentler ones. More like what if? than why not?

I started poking around outside the boundaries of logic. Looking into paganism, Wicca, earth-based spirituality. The idea that nature itself could be sacred – that resonated with me. That spirituality didn’t need to come from a pulpit. It could come from a mountain. A river. A breath. A seed. I realized I didn’t need to label myself anymore. I didn’t need to belong to a spiritual camp or defend a set of beliefs. I just needed to stay open. And that’s when everything started to expand.

I started reading about UFOlogy – at first because it was fascinating, strange, a bit taboo. But the deeper I went, the more it began to shift something in me. Not just the stories of flying discs and government coverups, but the real questions underneath them: What else is out there? What dimensions are we missing? What if “the other side” isn’t up or down, but sideways? I started learning about string theory, multiverses, nonlocal consciousness – the kinds of things that sound like science fiction until you realize there are actual physicists exploring them. It wasn’t all “woo.” It was math. It was possibility. And then I had my own experience. My first UFO sighting.

I won’t try to convince anyone of what I saw. That’s not the point. But I know what I saw. And in that moment, something inside me unlocked. I remember thinking – not in words, but in a kind of deep, full-body knowing – There’s so much more going on than we understand. That moment didn’t give me answers. But it gave me permission. To stop needing everything to be provable.

To start trusting what I felt. In college, I dove into it even further – studying world religions, philosophy, ethics, mysticism. And for the first time, I stopped looking at religion purely through the lens of what it had done wrong. I started seeing what it had done right. Every tradition had something. A thread. Whether it was compassion, service, devotion, presence, surrender, reverence, wonder – each belief system was a different language trying to say the same thing: There is more. And we belong to it. I started to meditate. Not because someone told me to – but because I needed silence. I needed stillness.

And in those quiet spaces, I began to feel something I hadn’t felt in years: peace. Not the peace of knowing – but the peace of not needing to know. I started reading books like Biocentrism – which bridges physics, consciousness, and metaphysics in ways that made me feel like science and spirituality weren’t opposites… they were different fingers pointing at the same moon. And all the while, I started to soften. I saw the good in people I used to write off. I realized that the most angry, judgmental, or bitter people are often the ones who’ve been the most hurt. And that nobody’s beliefs – or lack of belief – can be understood until you know the story underneath them.

I stopped needing a system to belong to. And I started learning to belong to the moment instead. And strangely, throughout all of this, there was one presence that kept following me – patiently, quietly, almost as if it was waiting for me to notice it. Gnomes.

Through It All, Gnomes

There’s something strange that happens when you start opening your mind. Not in a trendy, soundbath-on-a-retreat kind of way – but in a real, raw way. When your beliefs have been torn down, rebuilt, shattered again, and softened over time, you start noticing things you never would’ve paid attention to before. And that’s when the pattern started showing up. Gnomes. They weren’t part of my religious exploration. They weren’t in any of the books I was reading about string theory, consciousness, or ancient mysticism.

But somehow – they were always there. At first, I didn’t take it seriously. Why would I? They were decorations. Cute little statues for garden beds. The kind of thing you pass in someone’s yard and maybe smile at – maybe roll your eyes. But over time… they started to feel less like clutter and more like a thread. And when I started pulling on that thread, it unraveled into something I hadn’t expected. It started with memories. As a kid, I spent a lot of time at my grandparents’ house. I helped in the yard – mowing, weeding, watering. And every single time, my grandparents would make sure I knew: “Don’t break the gnome.” It was a running joke, but with seriousness beneath it.

They’d move it out of the way before I started working, like it was fragile – but more than that, important. Sacred in their own unspoken way. At the time, I didn’t think much of it. It was just part of the routine. But looking back now, I can see how even then, gnomes were treated with a kind of quiet reverence. Fast-forward to age 15 – fully immersed in my black-shirt, metalhead phase. My friend and I, driven by equal parts mischief and creativity, decided to “liberate” a gnome from someone’s yard and leave a ransom note. We told them to leave a bag of jelly beans at the local park if they wanted their gnome back. They never brought the jelly beans.

So, I kept the gnome…. And i still have it And that might’ve been the end of it… …but that moment set off a chain reaction I couldn’t have predicted. For my 16th birthday, my friends pulled off something unforgettable. They told me to come out to the car – and when I opened the door, it was filled to the brim with gnomes. Wall-to-wall. Piled on the seats, stuffed in the footwells, peeking out from every angle. Countless of them. They had “collected” them from various places – some more ethically than others. And from that day on, gnomes became my thing. A joke at first. But a joke that never ended.

From that year forward to this day, every birthday, every Christmas, every inside joke… came with another gnome. Eventually I had too many to count. And because I couldn’t risk putting them outside where neighbors might start asking questions, they filled my bedroom. I slept in a room full of gnomes for years. At some point, it stopped being funny – and started becoming normal. I didn’t think of it as spiritual. I didn’t call it anything. But it was constant. And it was mine. Years later, when I began opening my heart again – softening toward mystery, meditating more, listening to people from all walks of life – I found myself pulled into a different kind of education.

And that education came mostly at night. I’d stay up listening to Coast to Coast AM and Fade to Black Radio – every night. Hours and hours of people calling in to talk about everything from angels and shadow people to near-death experiences, numerology, astral projection, faeries, Bigfoot, and of course… UFOs. What struck me wasn’t whether these people were right or wrong. It was that they were willing to believe in something. They were willing to ask big questions and share experiences that most people would hide for fear of being ridiculed. And something in me softened further. I stopped needing everything to make sense.

I started to ask myself: What have I ignored or dismissed just because it seemed silly? And the answer hit me almost instantly. Gnomes. Not the statues, but what they stood for. They had been following me my whole life – not in a spooky way, but in a symbolic one. A quiet thread, weaving through every version of myself. They were there during my early encounters with the unseen.

They were there during my most rebellious, anti-spiritual years – sitting quietly in the corners of my room, watching. They were there as I started exploring metaphysics and grounded spirituality. And they never demanded anything. Never claimed to have the answers. They just… waited. The more I looked into their lore, the more I realized: Gnomes are guardians. Caretakers of the earth. Stewards of hidden realms.

Representatives of the in-between – between science and magic, between seen and unseen, between ancient myth and modern metaphor. They are rooted in folklore across the world. And while their stories vary, the heart of them remains the same: They’re the quiet protectors. The watchers. The ones who live close to nature, below the surface, and only show themselves when someone’s truly paying attention. And I started to see them as more than a childhood joke or a collector’s item.

They became a symbol of everything I was trying to hold in balance:

  • The rational and the intuitive
  • The scientific and the sacred
  • The playful and the profound

While the world pushed me to choose – left or right, believer or skeptic, spiritual or secular – gnomes just smiled quietly and reminded me that you don’t have to pick a side. You can live in the mystery. You can hold questions without needing conclusions. And maybe that’s what they were teaching me all along. That belief doesn’t always look like doctrine. Sometimes belief is just staying open. Sometimes it's knowing there’s something sacred about small things. About care. Stewardship. Listening. And maybe – just maybe – what we call folklore is a language we haven’t fully learned how to read yet.

So when I started dreaming of creating a space where people of all beliefs could come together… Where no one was shamed for asking questions… Where mystery could be honored instead of explained away… Where nature, kindness, and laughter were central… It didn’t feel like I was inventing something new. It felt like I was finally honoring something ancient. Gnomes didn’t demand my belief.

But they held it – through every phase, every shift, every story. And when I stopped running from that… The idea for the Church of Gnome came to life.

Founding the Church of Gnome

At a certain point in my journey, something started to crystallize – not in the form of answers, but in the shape of a question: What if belief isn’t about being right? What if it’s about being in relationship – with the world, with each other, with the mystery itself? It’s easy to think of belief as a destination. Something we arrive at. Something we defend. But what I’ve come to realize is that belief – real, lived belief – is more like a garden. It has seasons. It requires care. It asks us to pull weeds, to let things die, to plant new seeds when the time comes.

And whether your garden has looked the same your whole life, or whether you’ve torn it up and re-planted a dozen times – it’s still yours. Still sacred. For me, the Church of Gnome didn’t start with certainty. It started with an ache. An ache to belong somewhere that didn’t demand I fit a mold. A place that could hold questions without flinching, hold joy without shame, and hold contradictions without trying to fix them. But the more I reflected, the more I realized – this wasn’t just my ache. It’s one so many people carry, whether they’re changing their beliefs or holding fast to them.

Some people hold on to their faith like a lighthouse in a storm. Others let go, not because they stopped caring, but because the light that once guided them no longer matched the shape of their soul. And both of those people deserve somewhere to be. Together. The Church of Gnome isn’t about replacing belief. It’s about honoring it – all of it. The belief you’ve carried your whole life. The belief you’re only just starting to name.

The belief that doesn’t quite fit anywhere. The belief that’s more feeling than statement. It’s about creating a space where seekers and sages can sit at the same table. Because here’s the thing: Whether your faith has been steady as stone or shifting like wind through the trees, I believe we all carry the same longing: To feel connected. To feel rooted.

To live a life that matters – to us, and to something greater than us. And that’s where gnomes come in – not as a punchline, but as a portal. Gnomes, in their ancient lore, are guardians. Tenders of the land. Stewards of the earth and keepers of the quiet places. They live close to the soil. They move slowly. They listen more than they speak. They’re not the ones calling fire from the sky. They’re the ones making sure the roots don’t rot. And in a world so obsessed with being right, with being loud, with being seen – that quiet, rooted wisdom feels revolutionary.

To me, the gnome became a symbol of what I was seeking – and maybe what we’re all seeking in one form or another: Something that can hold the sacredness of the small. Something that can live at the crossroads of mystery and presence. Something that honors the invisible threads that run through our lives. The gnome, for me, is not just a statue or a myth. It’s an invitation. An invitation to slow down.

To pay attention. To live gently. To believe – not because someone told you to, but because your soul is whispering that there’s more. And it doesn’t matter whether that “more” looks like God, or the universe, or ancestral memory, or nothing you can name at all. What matters is the posture. The openness. The reverence.

That’s what the Church of Gnome is. It’s not about convincing you to believe in gnomes. It’s about reminding you that belief itself – when it’s held with care – is sacred. It’s about creating a space where people can come together across beliefs, united not by a shared theology, but by a shared humility. By a shared curiosity. By the desire to live thoughtfully, to laugh often, to care for this earth and each other while we’re here. Some people will find that through Jesus.

Some through Gaia. Some through meditation, or music, or math. And some of us… found it in gnomes. But what matters isn’t the symbol. What matters is the spirit behind it. That we believe something matters. That we believe wonder is worth preserving.

That we believe in honoring the unseen – not just the unseen world, but the unseen in each other. The grief no one knows we carry. The dreams we haven’t spoken aloud. The sacred strangeness that makes each of us who we are. So whether you’ve never questioned your beliefs, or whether you’ve changed them a hundred times… Whether you feel sure of your path or like you’re still stumbling around in the dark… You are welcome here.

Because belief is not a club. It’s a living thing. And the Church of Gnome is a garden where all kinds of belief – old and new, rooted and seeking – can grow side by side. We don’t have to agree. We just have to listen. To one another. To the earth.

To the quiet symbols that have been following us all our lives.

What stays with us

If there’s one thing I hope you take from this episode, it’s that you’re not alone. Whether your beliefs have shifted year after year, or you’ve carried the same faith like a trusted lantern through every storm – there’s room for you here. It’s okay to have questions. It’s okay to hold convictions. It’s okay to change. And it’s okay not to. Spiritual life isn’t a contest.

It’s not about who’s the most enlightened or who has the most ancient lineage or the deepest knowledge. It’s about honesty. About being honest with where you are, and what feels real to you. Some people find comfort in certainty. Others find it in wonder. Some want structure. Others crave mystery. We all carry the ache to understand – to feel anchored, even as the world shifts beneath us. And in that shared ache, we can find each other.

We can learn from one another. We can sit side by side – even if our beliefs look wildly different – and still feel connected through something deeper. Because belief, at its best, doesn’t divide us. It draws us into relationship – with ourselves, with each other, with whatever we sense beyond this moment. That’s what the Church of Gnome stands for. Not one path, but many. Not one story, but a shared space to tell our stories.

A place where playfulness and reverence live together. Where spiritual seekers, quiet believers, longtime faithful, and cosmic weirdos all have a seat at the same table. So wherever you are on your journey – whatever you believe, or don’t – I want you to hear this: You’re not lost. You’re on your way. And you don’t have to walk it alone. Thank you for being curious. And thank you for holding space – for me, for yourself, for this community we’re all building together.